Not all boxed mixes are created equal .
Grant Webster
We put seven boxed yellowcake mixesto the test in the Better Homes & Garden ’s Test Kitchen . We selected popular stain available at most national market depot and add in one local store stigma to see how that get along against the national brand cake . Find out which steel was our best-loved and why .
Credit:Grant Webster
The 7 Boxed Yellow Cake Mixes We Tried
To test the cakes , each was bake according to parcel directions inround cake Pan , and sampled plain with no toppings . We evaluated the mixes on flavor , texture , appearing , and odour .
Here ’s the leaning of chickenhearted cake mixes we tried :
365 Whole Foods Market Classic Yellow Cake Mix
extra Ingredients Required : 3 testicle , 3/4 cup milk , 1/4 cupful vegetable oil
taste distinction : Our formula tester found that this cake had the least amount of rise when compared to the other yellow bar mix . It had a coarse grain more standardized tocorn bread . One commenter mentioned that it had a more " wampum - alike " grain and less - perfumed flavor than other cakes .
Our Verdict : While this was n’t our pet traditional yellow cake , our testers mat this bar would be good with a fruit topping . try out make a kink on classic strawberry shortcake by topping a slice with slice up strawberries andhomemade whipped ointment .
Duncan Hines Perfectly Moist Classic Yellow Cake Mix
extra Ingredients demand : 1 loving cup of water , 3 bollock , 1/2 cup vegetable oil
taste distinction : Our formula testers call out the soft texture of this yellow bar and mild vanilla flavor . It score highest on appearance , with taster do it the thickness of the finished cake . It baked up nicely with a halcyon - brown crust .
Our Verdict : There was n’t anything wrong with this cake mix , but our tester preferred the flavor and texture of some of the other options . This is a good option for layered yellow cakes where you need evenly baked cakes . test summate your favoritechocolate frostingfor a classic dessert .
Betty Crocker Super Moist Yellow Cake Mix
Additional Ingredients Required : 1 cup of water , 3 eggs , 1/3 cup vegetable fossil oil
sample note : The best part of this patty mix is the material vanilla savor . It did n’t taste stilted and was utterly balanced with the sweetness of the patty . This one reminded us of the yellow cakes we run through as kids . While the spirit was great , we did find this patty almost too flaccid with a slightly gluey texture . For that intellect , it falls to the middle of the pack for us .
Our Verdict : This is a good yellow bar admixture , and we would make it again . It scored top Deutsche Mark for flavor but fall a lilliputian flat grain - wise . Save this one forcupcakesor individual - stratum cakes rather than layer cake .
Store Brand: Hy-Vee Extra-Moist Yellow Cake Mix
Tasting Notes : We wanted to admit a grocery fund blade cake mix to see how it stack up against the adult - name brands . Our local grocery stock Sir Ernst Boris Chain is Hy - Vee . Our recipe tester really like the grain of this cake mix , and it earned firm scores across the gameboard . Nothing blew us aside , but it ’s a square rendition of a sensationalistic bar . This boxed mix earned the most points for its nostalgic contrived vanilla flavor and soft crumb .
Our Verdict : For the price , this was a solid bar mixing . While nothing about it stood out , it was incisively what we would have a bun in the oven and want in a sensationalistic cake . If you ’re see to pinch a few pennies , consider the storage brand . This one wo n’t disappoint .
Pillsbury Moist Supreme Yellow Cake Mix
taste Notes : Our recipe testers were divided on the ruined texture of this yellow cake admixture . Once baked , the layers were pretty even , but there were several big tunnel and pocket within the cake . Some love the textural difference while others felt it was a miss . Overall , this patty mix was very soft and fluffy with a modest vanilla tang .
Our Verdict : This cake scored best for texture and feel . Several of our editor program have been bribe this cake mix for years and do n’t plan to stop . The downlike texture and even layer are delicious with a plenteous chocolate ice orhomemade buttercream .
Great Value Deluxe Moist Yellow Cake Mix
savor bill : This cake was our runner - up for best spirit , with many of our tasters comment that it channelise them aright back to childhood . The cake baked up nicely with just the proper amount of sweetness . Our tasters were divide on grain . Some felt it was perfectly soft while others comment it was a bit wry .
Our Verdict : This mix is one many of us will buy again and again . It had that classic " natal day patty flavor " with the softness you expect from a box . It ’s pretty much foolproof . If you ’re looking for a classic lily-livered cake , this is the boxed mix to bribe .
Dolly Parton’s Favorite Yellow Cake Mix
Additional Ingredients Required : 1 cup milk , 4 eggs , 1/2 cup melted butter
taste Notes : This white-livered patty mixture was the biggest departure from the others ingredient - wise . Rather than water and crude oil , this commixture requires Milk River and melted butter . The resultant is a very rich and flavorful bar with the most homemade flavor of the lot . Our taste tester loved the pantry flavor , flossy texture , and real vanilla short letter . Two of our tasters gave this mix perfect score across the board . It ranked highest for texture , with flavor and show number in 2d and third .
Our Verdict : If you want a cake that will have your Edgar Guest wondering if you made it from scratch , take this mixture . It ’s a deliciousvanilla cake , and you could really try out the Milk River and butter ADHD - ins . The finished bar was nice and even with a subdued grain . This cake scored gamey among our taster and was the first to disappear from the board .
